Dear Rabbi

A rabbi friend forwarded me an email about an upcoming protest at a synagogue by a hate group that calls itself a Baptist church. Below is what I wrote back to my friend.

Dear Rabbi,

It was with much sadness I read the email you forwarded about an extremist Baptist group that plans to engage in an anti-Jewish protest outside a synagogue. This group, from what I understand, is radically anti-homosexual and usually targets venues where homosexuality is promoted or tolerated. I did not know, but am not surprised, that they are also anti-Jewish. Please understand that Baptist churches are autonomous. One Baptist church has no control over another, and even Baptist organizations and umbrella groups cannot tell an individual congregation what to do. The most they can do to discipline a congregation is to withdraw fellowship. Westboro Baptist Church in Topeka describes itself as an “Old School Primitive Baptist Church.” It is not a member of the Southern Baptist Convention, the American Baptist Churches, USA, or any of the other major Baptist organizations.

Groups like Westboro Baptist Church do not reflect the tradition of those early Baptists who stood boldly for freedom and toleration, like Roger Williams, founder of Rhode Island and organizer of the first Baptist church in America. He was not only one of the first Americans to advocate freedom of religion, but he also stood for the abolition of slavery and equal treatment of Native Americans. Or take Baptist preacher John Leland, for example, who was one of the most eloquent spokesmen for religious liberty. He worked with his friend James Madison to get Thomas Jefferson’s Religious Freedom Act passed in the Virginia state assembly in 1786. Not only did he advocate religious liberty, he also opposed slavery on moral grounds. You may also be aware that at the time Baptists founded Brown University (as the College of Rhode Island) it was the first institution of higher education to admit people regardless of their religious affiliation or beliefs.

I know it may sound a little defensive to rehearse some of the Baptist roots of toleration, but I need to remind myself that those modern-day Baptist who specialize in hate speech do not reflect the mild and godly heritage of our tradition, which was founded by many victims of persecution and intolerance.

While I support the free speech rights of those who protest peacefully, I apologize to you and all those of your faith tradition who are being targeted by people who call themselves Baptists. It is a shameful thing.


J. Travis Moger



Filed under issues

4 responses to “Dear Rabbi

  1. Miriam M

    Professor Moger,
    A beautiful reply to a sad situation. I hope your friend receives it with understanding. Unfortunate situations cannot be adequately explained, but describing the context helps one to show more grace to the aggressors who themselves are caught in an unfortunate system of lies and deceit.

    Miriam (former history student at PHC)

    PS We at PHC still miss you!

  2. Miriam,

    Thank you for your kind words and insightful comments. I hope you will post again in the future.

    I miss you and my other former students too! Please send me an email when you get a chance. I’d like to hear how you’ve been and what you’re up to.


  3. Glenn Bratcher

    Hello Travis,

    This is a really nice and appropriate response to the Rabbi. To be honest, I have wondered what I could say to those who have asked for my opinion…on matters similar to this sad situation. (It is totally beyond defending.)

    But now I know what I can say…with conviction.
    I agree with you! May the Rabbi receive your words and feel the love behind them!

    Thank you…and God Bless You…you express your thoughts very well.


  4. Amy Philips

    Travis you have eloquently stated you position on this most dispicable situation. Obviosly the people protesting do know their Christian roots and origin. Hopefully some will happen onto this site and see the error of their ways. As my mother usted to say, “your rights leave off where another’s begin”. The freedom of religion is one of our basic rights. Proud to have you as my son-in-law. Amy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s